The settlement tied to Jason Arno’s 2023 line-of-duty death is the largest involving the Buffalo Fire Department and follows a report citing missed mayday calls, poor accountability and equipment issues

BUFFALO, N.Y. — The city of Buffalo will pay nearly $6 million to settle a wrongful death lawsuit tied to the death of Buffalo Firefighter Jason Arno.

Arno died in the line of duty on March 1, 2023, while battling a fire at 745 Main Street, WIVB reported. His family had filed the lawsuit alleging negligence related to the fire and response.

| BETTER EVERY SHIFT: Dena Ali: How leaders shape firefighter wellness

The $5.9 million settlement was reached just before trial and still needs council approval, which is expected to be a procedural matter. It is the largest involving the Buffalo Fire Department in the city’s history.

A 2025 report found several problems during the fire response, including poor accountability, faulty equipment, limited officer training, heavy radio traffic and no emergency headcount after evacuation.

“We would hope this would bring accountability,” Charles Desmond, the attorney representing Arno’s estate, said. “I think the size of the settlement, and they have also begun to change their safety protocols, rules and regulations going forward, and the family wants to see more. They are going to be actively involved.”

The fire department reported several findings related to the fire response and the conditions surrounding Arno’s death, including:

• Four mayday calls from Arno were missed amid excessive radio traffic from two fire events.
• On-scene personnel did not attempt radio contact with Arno after he went down.
• An emergency headcount was requested but not completed.
• Firefighters’ breathing apparatus had Bluetooth capability for emergency evacuation alerts, but the supporting software had not been purchased.
• The report cited improper training and procedures.
• Another firefighter near Arno lost contact and communication with him.

The lawsuit also alleged negligence and carelessness by property managers and contractors working at the building that day.

The firefighters’ union declined to comment. Buffalo Mayor Sean Ryan said the settlement avoids a long trial and may provide some closure for Arno’s family.

Middlebury firefighters found heavy fire on the second floor and exterior of the Carriage Drive home

A possible fuel-related explosion aboard a 40-foot cabin cruiser near the Haulover Sandbar sparked a mass-casualty response

Twenty-six workers were safely evacuated from Platform Habitat 9 miles off the Southern California coast

Fire crews battled large wildfires in Broward and Miami-Dade counties as smoke reduced visibility, forced road closures

MagneGrip delivers fully integrated clean air solutions to protect firefighter health by combining source-capture exhaust removal with air purification systems that continuously improve the quality of the air circulating throughout the station